Decision Summary Information

Back to Results | Search Again | Most Recent Decisions

Decision Number: TC 04523
Appellant: Robert Ames
Respondent: The Commissioners for Her Majesty's Revenue & Customs
Chairmen / Special
Commissioners:
ANNE REDSTON
Date Of Decision: 07/07/2015
Main Category: INCOME TAX/CORPORATION TAX
Main Subcategory: Exemptions and reliefs
Notes: CAPITAL GAINS TAX – Enterprise Investment Scheme – eligible shares – EIS income tax relief not claimed because income below personal allowance – whether CGT exemption only available if EIS relief claimed – whether the legislation should be interpreted “purposively” on a reverse Ramsay basis –whether the legislation can be “read down” under the Human Rights Act section 3 – HMRC refusal to allow late claim – whether TMA s 118(2) allows a late claim on the basis of reasonable excuse – whether Tribunal has jurisdiction over HMRC’s care and management powers – appeal dismissed.
Decision(s) to Download: TC04523.pdf TC04523.pdf